#263 Finding COVID – How Good is the Test to Detect it?
CLINICAL QUESTION
What is the chance of obtaining an incorrect result with the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) test for COVID-19?
BOTTOM LINE
If the PCR COVID-19 test is positive you have COVID-19 (specificity ~100%). Small Canadian studies suggest the test will detect COVID-19 ~80-90% of the time (sensitivity), although estimates range from ~50%-90%. Collection technique, anatomical sample and timing of collection influence these numbers. The chance of a false negative depends on sensitivity and the pre-test probability the person has COVID-19. Example: someone with abnormal chest x-rays and close COVID-19 positive contacts has a higher risk of false negatives than someone who is asymptomatic.
Reading Tools for Practice Article can earn you MainPro+ Credits
Join NowAlready a CFPCLearn Member? Log in
EVIDENCE
Hospitalized patients in China:
- Retrospective study, 1014 patients, COVID-19 symptoms, all underwent both CT chest and PCR.1
- Using CT chest and symptoms as the “gold standard”:
- PCR sensitivity 68% (601/888).
- Using PCR as the “gold standard”:
- CT chest sensitivity 97% (580/601).
- Using CT chest and symptoms as the “gold standard”:
- Samples from various anatomic sites:
- 866 samples from 213 inpatients who previously tested positive.2 Sensitivity of swabs collected 0-7 and 8-14 days after symptom onset:
- Sputum: 83% (45/54) and 77% (47/61).
- Nasal: 72% (158/219) and 58% (130/226).
- Throat: 61% (58/95) and 41% (26/63).
- 866 samples from 213 inpatients who previously tested positive.2 Sensitivity of swabs collected 0-7 and 8-14 days after symptom onset:
- 1070 specimens from 205 patients (disease course not reported):3,4
- Sensitivity of bronchoalveolar lavage 93%, sputum 72%, nasal/nostril swabs 63%, and pharyngeal swabs (oral or nasopharyngeal) 32%.
- Nasopharyngeal 90%.
- Throat 87%.
- Nasal 80%.
- Saliva 77%.
- Inappropriate specimen collection, storage, and transport are likely the biggest contributors to false negative results.8-10
- Chance of false negatives depends on both sensitivity and pre-test probability (the chance of having the disease).
- Sensitivities of PCR are between 90% and 50%.
- If pre-test probability is ≤10% (example minimally symptomatic patient in community): False negatives from 1% to 5%.
- If pre-test probability is ~80% (example hospitalized patient with x-ray findings and known exposure): False negatives from 8% to 40%.
- While not a reliable indicator of prevalence, positive rates for COVID-19 testing are persistently below 10% in Canada.11
Latest Tools for Practice
#373 Strategies for initiating insulin in type 2 diabetes
What is the optimal initial insulin for patients with type 2 diabetes?
#372 Mission Slimpossible Part 2: Oral GLP-1 agonists for weight loss
Are oral GLP-1 agonists effective for weight loss?
#371 It’s time to challenge penicillin allergy labels!
Can low-risk patients with beta-lactam allergy receive an oral beta-lactam challenge safely?
PCR test has false negatives