#78 Lung Cancer Screening – Low dose CT, High dose False Positives
CLINICAL QUESTION
Does screening high-risk individuals with low dose CT (LDCT) result in reduced lung cancer mortality?
BOTTOM LINE
Benefit from screening for lung cancer with LDCT has been demonstrated in only one trial, without a “usual care” group. The high number of false positives, which require further, sometimes invasive investigations, is worrisome. Smoking cessation should remain the priority to decrease lung cancer mortality.
Reading Tools for Practice Article can earn you MainPro+ Credits
Join NowAlready a CFPCLearn Member? Log in
EVIDENCE
National Lung Screening Trial (NLST), 53,454 current or former smokers (at least 30 packyears), aged 55-74 years without history of cancer. Randomized to three annual screening exams with LDCT or chest x-ray (CXR), followed for an additional five years.1
- Lung cancer mortality: 1.3% LDCT versus 1.7% CXR.
- Number Needed to Screen (NNS)=306 to prevent one lung cancer death over eight years. 2
- Overall mortality: 7.0% LDCT versus 7.5% CXR, NNS=217.
- Concerns:
- Amongst the 26,309 patients screened with LDCT, there were a total of 18,146 positive LDCTs.
- 96.4% of positive LDCTs were false positives.
- Possible over diagnosis of cancers that would never have become clinically important.
- No placebo group.
- Amongst the 26,309 patients screened with LDCT, there were a total of 18,146 positive LDCTs.
- Baseline CXR and sputum, then yearly medicals.3
- 2472 patients, 34 month follow up: Relative Risk (RR)=0.97 (CI 0.71-1.32).
- Annual questionnaires and lung function testing.4
- 4104 patients, 58 month follow-up: RR=1.15 (CI 0.83-1.61).
- Screening with CXR does not reduce lung cancer mortality.5,6
- Positive LDCTs require further investigations (i.e. additional imaging, bronchoscopy or needle biopsy).1,3,4,7
- Complications of transthoracic needle biopsy include hemorrhage (1%), pneumothorax (15%) and pneumothorax requiring chest tube (6.6%).8
- Estimates of LDCT radiation harm: one additional cancer death per 2500 persons screened annually for three years.9
- The American Lung Association and others now recommend LDCT screening for high risk individuals. 10,11
- A 65 year-old male smoker has a 5.9% risk of dying from lung cancer in the next 10 years compared to a 0.4% risk for non-smokers.12 This risk declines with smoking cessation.13
Latest Tools for Practice
#370 Antibiotics or no antibiotics for acute diverticulitis, that is the question!
Do antibiotics change clinical outcomes for patients with acute uncomplicated diverticulitis?
#369 Remind me, do medications that target brain amyloid improve my dementia?
Are amyloid-targeting monoclonal antibodies safe and effective for mild cognitive impairment or Alzheimer’s dementia?
#368 Sodium Restriction in Heart Failure: Beneficial or pouring salt in the wound?
Does sodium restriction improve outcomes in patients with chronic heart failure?
