#385 Topical minoxidil for androgenetic alopecia: When blood pressure agents make you hairy
CLINICAL QUESTION
How effective is topical minoxidil for androgenetic alopecia?
BOTTOM LINE
In men and women, topical minoxidil improves hair density by about 21 hairs/cm2 versus 5-9 (placebo) after 16-48 weeks. Oral and topical minoxidil are similarly effective albeit with different adverse effects. Finasteride is likely more effective than topical minoxidil in men.
Reading Tools for Practice Article can earn you MainPro+ Credits
Join NowAlready a CFPCLearn Member? Log in
EVIDENCE
- Results statistically significant unless indicated.
- One systematic review of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) with extractable data of topical minoxidil, past 5 years.1 After 16-48 weeks:
- Women:
- Versus placebo: 1
- Additional hairs/cm2 over placebo: 12-14 (2-4 RCTs, 476-717 participants).
- Example 21 additional hairs/cm2 minoxidil versus 9 (placebo).
- Additional hairs/cm2 over placebo: 12-14 (2-4 RCTs, 476-717 participants).
- Additional RCT topical versus oral minoxidil (52 participants): 2
- 1mg oral versus topical 5% once-daily:
- Additional hairs/cm2, global improvement: No difference.
- 1mg oral versus topical 5% once-daily:
- Versus placebo: 1
- Men:
- Versus placebo: 1
- Additional hairs/cm2 over placebo: 8-15 (4-10 RCTs, 598-1207 participants).
- Example 21 versus 5 (placebo).
- Additional hairs/cm2 over placebo: 8-15 (4-10 RCTs, 598-1207 participants).
- Additional RCT topical versus oral minoxidil (90 participants): 3
- 5mg oral versus topical 5% twice-daily:
- Additional hairs/cm2: No difference.
- Proportion with improvement at vertex: 46% versus 70% (oral); no difference at frontal areas.
- 5mg oral versus topical 5% twice-daily:
- Additional RCTs topical minoxidil versus 1mg oral finasteride:
- Topical 2% twice-daily (99 participants): 4
- Additional hair/0.49cm2 (baseline: 61-65): 9.6 versus 18 (finasteride).
- “Improvement”: No difference.
- Topical 5% twice-daily (65 participants): 5
- Improvement: 52% versus 80% (finasteride).
- Topical 2% twice-daily (99 participants): 4
- Versus placebo: 1
- Adverse effects, examples:
- Hypertrichosis (25% topical versus 49% oral),3 headaches (2% topical versus 14% oral).3 No meaningful changes in blood pressure/heart rate with oral.2,3
- Scalp eczema (16% topical versus 2% oral).3
- Shedding (9-16% oral/topical).3
- Loss of libido 0% (minoxidil oral/topical) versus 15% (finasteride).5
- Limitations: Clinical significance of hairs/cm2 unclear, few studies looking at patient satisfaction, RCTs often unblinded, mostly in 30-40 year-old men, high drop-out rates.
CONTEXT
- Health-related quality-of-life impairments with androgenetic alopecia comparable/greater than acne vulgaris.6
- In men, higher efficacy topical minoxidil with higher concentration: 19 additional hairs/cm2 (5%) versus 13 (2%), and patient assessment scores higher (51 on 100-point scale versus 41 for 2%).7
- Severe scalp symptoms also higher with higher concentration: 4% versus 1%.
- Inconsistent results in women.8
Latest Tools for Practice
#387 Side effects of long-term PPI use: Leaving a bad taste in your mouth?
What are the side effects of long-term proton pump inhibitor (PPI) use?
#386 The Bland Supremacy: Salt and cardiovascular disease
Does reducing sodium intake or substituting table salt with sodium-potassium alternatives improve cardiovascular outcomes?
#385 Topical minoxidil for androgenetic alopecia: When blood pressure agents make you hairy
How effective is topical minoxidil for androgenetic alopecia?
Complete Activity
good to know that minoxidil used for 16-48 week to improve the outcome
Oral finesteride best
I agree with the concept that oral finasteride is more effective than topical minoxidil.
what are the cost differences between the treatments?
Any difference in velocity of hair loss after stopping minoxidil vs Finasteride?
i am not keen on oral finasteride given. the risk of significant longterm side effects to men
Finasteride orally to be tried before topical minoxidil
Worth considering
Always good results when po used
ED is generally less common with topical Minoxidil yet less effective than oral Finasteride. A potentially bitter, but sometimes tolerable pill to swallow, requiring monitoring and medication change, if necessary.
ED is generally less common with topical Minoxidil yet generally less effective than either oral Minoxidil or Finasteride. A potentially bitter, but sometimes tolerable pill to swallow, requiring monitoring and medication change, if necessary.